There’s a common belief that honey is a surplus product that bees willingly share, but in reality, honey is made by bees to sustain themselves during winter or times of scarcity. Despite its “all-natural” appeal, the process of harvesting honey is inherently exploitative.

Beyond the ethical concerns, the honey industry is having a profound and often harmful effect on the environment. So, why is “Big Honey” such an environmental problem, and how is it impacting local bee populations?

How the Honey Industry Harms the Environment

The honey industry is big business—worth over $299.62 million in the U.S. alone, according to Statista. But this thriving industry comes with environmental consequences. Commercial honey operations, especially large-scale ones, are contributing to the decline of native bee populations. This is because honeybees, though essential for pollination, are extreme generalists when it comes to foraging. They often dominate the floral resources in a given area, leaving little for other species.

As reported by Scientific American, commercial honeybees have already begun to outcompete wild bee species that are already in decline for other reasons. The honeybee’s ability to thrive in a wide range of ecosystems can be both beneficial and harmful. While honeybees are effective pollinators, their introduction into new plant-pollinator ecosystems often disrupts the biodiversity of those systems. In some cases, they even crowd out other essential pollinators, including native bees.

In a way, honeybees can become a form of insect monoculture, pushing out native species that may otherwise thrive in the same environment. This could have lasting consequences for the biodiversity of entire ecosystems.

Ethical Considerations in Beekeeping | Beekeeping Academy | Ep. 11

Video by UFhoneybeelab

The Ethical Issues Behind Honey Production

Aside from the environmental impact, honey production raises ethical concerns similar to those found in industrial animal husbandry. Commercial beekeepers focus on maximizing honey yields, often at the expense of the bees’ wellbeing. To sustain bee colonies while harvesting honey, beekeepers replace the bees’ natural food stores with sugar substitutes, which lack essential nutrients necessary for the bees’ health.

This drive for higher productivity also leads to selective breeding practices, which reduce genetic diversity in bee populations. This weakens the bees’ immune systems, making them more susceptible to diseases that can spread to native bee populations, contributing to the collapse of colonies across the board.

The Issue with Local Beekeepers

Even smaller, local beekeepers, who may seem more attuned to the wellbeing of their bees, can also contribute to environmental problems. While many small-scale apiarists care deeply about their bees, they often unknowingly contribute to ecological imbalances. According to NPR, many conservation organizations promote local honey, but the truth is that honeybees don’t need much help from beekeepers. Unlike other bee species that play vital roles in pollination, honeybees are not at risk of extinction in the near future.

Honeybees, much like mustangs, are an agricultural transplant. While they may seem harmless, they can actually crowd out local bee populations if not carefully managed. Even a small hive of honeybees can create competition for food resources, threatening native species that rely on specific plants for survival.

The Threat of Honeybees Dominating the Landscape

If left unchecked, honeybees could become the dominant species in many ecosystems, crowding out thousands of other pollinators. This could have devastating effects on plant diversity, as certain plants may become over-pollinated, leading to monocultures that harm the entire ecosystem. While it may seem far-fetched, the threat of honeybees overwhelming native species is a real concern, one that could disrupt the delicate balance of many ecosystems.

While honeybees are undoubtedly important to agriculture and food production, the widespread, unchecked growth of the honey industry is putting native wildlife and ecosystems at risk. It’s time to consider how we can strike a balance between harvesting honey and protecting the natural world that depends on a diverse and healthy bee population.